April 25, 2006
Moral Obligation?

Some (alleged) chick has staked a claim at "myspace", this online community thing, and posted an unused e-mail address at one of my domain names which means whenever someone updates her (if she is, indeed, a she) "space" by posting comments or the like, I get the notifications.

I wanted to put a stop to this by following the link that myspace puts into the notification e-mails, but then I'd get asked for a password, which of course I don't have. Well. Since the e-mail is coming to me anyway, I simply clicked on "I forgot my password", and lo and behold, the password was e-mailed to me. I logged in and checked out this (alleged) chick's settings. I figured that if I could find an alternate e-mail address or something, I could just remove the address that is dropping mail into my e-mail box and set up everything to go to "her" other address.

Myspace has made the news a bit lately because it is a community that attracts teens, and there have been some infamous recent events where adult predators have been posing as teens on the online community to set up real-world meetings with actual teens. This kind of nastiness aside, there are other kinds of pretenders who create an alter ego on this or other on-line communities to pose as someone they are not, often to become a disruptive member of whatever groups they end up joining. It's all very strange and clearly involves people who have much more free time than I have, but it is also the reason I put my tongue-in-cheek when I allude to this chick as an (alleged) chick.

That all said, after poking around this account's settings, I've come to believe that the account really was set up by a high school-aged girl who lives in some other state in some town I've never heard of. The account settings that are not revealed in the public areas of myspace (but which I can see, because I have the password) lead me to believe that this girl typed in an e-mail address at one of my domains as a simple mistake (and no, I won't post the details that lead me to this conclusion), and there are other indications that this is not a hoax identity.

This leaves me with a quandary. I was unable to find any other e-mail settings (apparently, you can only set up one e-mail address for your myspace account), but I have the girl's name and hometown... and, of course, complete access to her myspace account until she changes her e-mail address setting. It's not enough for her to change her password -- every time she changes her password, I'll get the e-mail that confirms it.

So... do I have a moral obligation to notify her that she has given a complete stranger access to her myspace account? Does being a good citizen require me to try to track down a home phone number or contact her high school or e-mail one of her "friends" on her contact list in order to get word to her that she's made this error? (Words cannot convey how resistant I am to that idea.) Or, does being a good citizen require me to dead-letter an e-mail address on one of my domains, the electronic equivalent of turning a blind eye?

What do *you* think?

Posted by on April 25, 2006 08:58 AM in the following Department(s): Tidbits

 Comments

Well, failure to notify is, at worst, a venial sin rather than a mortal one. If you don't tell her, she won't get "Important Service Updates." Ho-hum.

I don't think you have to work very hard to fulfill this obligation -- just post a comment on her site that her e-mail address is typed in wrong, and that she should fix it. You need not explicitly state the address to which her e-mail is currently going, and you needn't try to contact her by other means. Neither are you required to "donate" an e-mail address to her.

If you're not using that e-mail address, I'd shut it down. If MySpace has a policy of shutting down sites that have invalid e-mail addresses, then you may want to wait a reasonable time after posting your comment, so that she has an opportunity to correct the problem.

Yours,
the ethicist

Posted by: Allen on April 25, 2006 11:20 AM

What you can do is post a blog entry on myspace. It's got one built in and say that her posted email address is going to your email and to ask to have it changed. That would be the nice thing. If she doesn't do that, then delete it.

If you delete the account, the worst that will happen is that she'll create a new one, perhaps with the right email address. You can go to account settings and then at the top there is a cancel account.

Since she put in the email address wrong, she probably doesn't realize it and is not getting into her account. If she did it on purpose, well, she is harassing you inadvertently and clogging up your email. So it's really more of an inconvenience to you since you don't know her and don't have any other easy way of getting in touch with her. Don't spend too much time on it. You've got other things to do.

Posted by: Ling on April 26, 2006 8:40 AM

Reminds me of an incident about a decade ago back when I was living in that condo in Tewksbury. Some wholesaler kept calling my phone number thinking they were calling a customer. They were trying to settle an unpaid bill.

At first I ignored the calls but after 5 or 6 I figured I'd let them know they had a wrong number. Instead of saying "Thanks for letting us know" the person who answered started threatening me so I just hung up.

Well, they kept calling and it's hard to convey to exact tone of their messages but by the end when I had their number blocked I was pretty sure they knew I wasn't their customer but thought they could get some money out of me anyway if they threatened to break my arms enough times.

That made me a bit leary of jumping in and being a good samaritan for strangers. I still try to do the right thing but you have to watch your own back at times.

If I were you I'd just set the email address in the account to postmaster@myspace.com and forget the whole thing.

Posted by: Peter Schoaff on April 26, 2006 7:24 PM

Oh bleh.. come on isn't anyone else just a little curious? Ok so you have two angels on one shoulder but I am going to be the little devil on the other.. muaaahahaha As a myspace user I can tell you there isn't anything she won't recieve from them.. expect of course those password confirmations. The only question that comes to my mind is how did she originally confirm her account? She would have had to of logged into your email and done that to have ever been able to log into myspace. But thats neither here nor there. I figure its a low level hack, as long as you don't start spamming her out, changing her site, or anything that could be harmful to her in the long run. God who wouldn't love to be a fly on the wall in someone else's myspace back office rofl. And I know I said you should change anything but the truly twisted side of me would keep changing one thing around just to see if she would catch on and maybe register a new space. (was thinking like her age lol) *little devil nudges you and winks*

Posted by: So~and~So on May 19, 2006 3:56 PM

 Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


Home Page:


Comments:


Remember info?




Copyright (c)1998 - 2010 by Allan Rousselle. All rights reserved, all wrongs reversed, all reservations righted, all right, already.
Click here to send me mail.

The author. January, 2010.
S e a r c h   T h i s   S i t e



D e p a r t m e n t s


R e c e n t   E n t r i e s


R e c e n t   C o m m e n t s

On May 19, So~and~So said:
"Oh bleh.. come on isn't anyone else just a li..." on entry: Moral Obligation?.

On Apr 26, Peter Schoaff said:
"Reminds me of an incident about a decade ago ..." on entry: Moral Obligation?.

On Apr 26, Ling said:
"What you can do is post a blog entry on myspa..." on entry: Moral Obligation?.

On Apr 25, Allen said:
"Well, failure to notify is, at worst, a venia..." on entry: Moral Obligation?.

F r i e n d s


A r c h i v e s


O t h e r   L i n k s